Score: 10

"Wonderful"

submission: The Rain Falls

date: December 21, 2009

I really loved the melody of this entire song, but the rain sound effect became very distracting and annoying as the song went on. I think if it faded out at some point earlier on in the song, it would allow the main melody to shine through. The harp does an amazing job of illustrating rain falling though and I don't think the rain is really needed. Again, love this song =D

Score: 10

"Well Mastered"

submission: MMZX - Trap Factory

date: December 16, 2009

It is really well mastered. Everything pops so nicely. I haven't heard the original, but this is really great work. I greatly enjoyed listening to it =)

Score: 10

"Awesome!"

submission: Glass Fish - Inside the Whale

date: December 9, 2009

While I never got that far into the game, I really love this song -- it's just great. It also reminds me of some old Castlevania music at 0:40...

Score: 10

"Epic"

submission: The Land of the Forgotten

date: December 9, 2009

It is just amazing, it's hard to put it into words... It really does not get repetitive at all and also makes a great ringtone, too! =D

Score: 8

"Well done..."

submission: Song # 2 (T.O.F)

date: July 16, 2009

It was overall good. Mostly after the crack/crash at 0:35, it would have sounded better had you come back in with drums or a deep bass to kick it in. That being merely my opinion, the rest of the song is really neat and you did a good job putting it together. The only other thing is you really need to name your songs!!! Try and think of something creative to title them.

Score: 6

"Not bad..."

submission: Song # 4 (T.O.F)

date: July 16, 2009

I really loved the beginning, it had a great hook. But, at 1:28, the drums coming in sounded a bit off timing-wise and was a bit rough. Those drums in general just didn't seem to fit. And from about 0:56 when the saw synth sorta comes in randomly, it begins to sound chaotic, but not in a good way. As the song goes on, it gets rather cluttered, then at 3:00, when everything drops, and just that lone synth loop played, it let me hear the main melody, which is really cool, I just wish it was more distinguishable throughout the rest of the song. The drum transition at 3:46 was better. Overall, now that I'm done criticizing this song, it had a really great beginning and an even better end, I did enjoy the end greatly. The middle is the only part needing work.

Score: 7

"Pretty good..."

submission: Song # 6 (T.O.F)

date: July 16, 2009

It flowed well, and had a neat beat. I like the part that is the windy kinda whoosh in the background from about 1:24 - 2:48. That's really cool sounding.

Score: 9

"Nice Melody!"

submission: Song # 9 (T.O.F)

date: July 16, 2009

I gotta say the beginning was a bit odd, but as the song went on the melody came in, I just smiled and kept on listening. The melody is really, almost annoyingly catchy, haha, and that is just awesome!!

Score: 10

"This is really awesome!!!!"

submission: Song # 3 (T.O.F)

date: July 16, 2009

I happened to hear this through the NG Audio Portal Radio, and I had to download it. It's just such a neat song with great variety and nice transitions. This is really good man, keep it up. Is this song actually called Unknown Singularity? Because the download file said that and that's a cool name too! =)

Score: 6

"Odd..."

submission: Wormhole Generator

date: July 2, 2009

Haha, you made this in Garageband, didn't you? I recognize the spooky please hang up and try again voice. It is a bit off, not all the parts match up (mostly the drums) and while I assume you were going for the kind chaotic approach, it would sound a bit better if the sounds complimented each other, rather than clashing near the end. After the alarm was just random. I lol'd at that. Keep experimenting with things and work on the timing of the drums. Try listening to some other songs on Newgrounds to get some ideas.